This paper explores the inconsistencies between traditional cultural beliefs and Western parenting techniques in the African-Igbo context within a globalized society. Anchored in Social Learning Theory, the study underscores how Igbo parenting has historically emphasized discipline, communal responsibility, respect for elders, and cultural transmission through proverbs, storytelling, and extended family involvement. In contrast, Western parenting often prioritizes independence, individualism, and negotiation, resulting in cultural conflict when these approaches intersect. Using a survey design and NVivo analysis of responses from 264 Igbo parents and young adults, the study examines perceptions of traditional values, challenges in adapting to Western customs, and the extent of integration between the two. Findings reveal that while the majority of parents strongly value traditional teachings (coded under the “Cultural Anchoring” node), they also acknowledge significant tensions when these practices are compared with modern methods. Although many respondents expressed confusion about Western approaches, the greatest difficulty identified was balancing both systems. Partial blending of traditional and modern practices is evident, but complete integration remains contested. The research suggests that Igbo parenting represents a stage of cultural negotiation, with tradition acting as the anchor while modern influences remain unavoidable. The study highlights implications for education, discipline, and cultural identity, while recommending cultural education programs, parent workshops, intergenerational dialogue, community support networks, and policy advocacy to preserve heritage and equip children for life in multicultural settings.